A St. Peter, Minnesota nurse has sued the federal government, alleging immigration agents pointed guns at her, pulled her from her car and kneeled on her after she merely watched one of their operations from nearby.
Jamie Martens, 47, a registered nurse, filed the federal complaint over an arrest she says happened last winter, MPR News reported Nov. 10. She is seeking $550,000 in damages for assault, battery, false arrest, negligence and emotional distress, suing under a federal law that allows certain claims against the government for the conduct of its employees.
What the lawsuit says happened
According to the complaint, agents in multiple vehicles followed Martens’ car after she left the scene of an immigration enforcement operation she had been observing with others nearby. The agents never signaled they were law enforcement, the complaint alleges, before boxing her car in once she had stopped and pointing guns at her. Agents then pulled her from the vehicle and kneeled on her, according to the filing. Martens has a degenerative joint disease in both hips, and the complaint says the kneeling re-aggravated that injury, leaving her with chronic back pain; she also says the encounter caused her PTSD, Fox 9 reported.
The government’s version
A Department of Homeland Security statement cited in the reporting called Martens “an agitator” and said she tried to ram agents and drove recklessly. Martens disputes that account in her complaint. The lawsuit does not name the agents involved, listing them only as John Does 1 through 5. Under the law governing claims like hers, a federal agency has roughly six months to respond to an administrative claim before a person can sue in court; MPR News reported that after more than six months passed without a decision on Martens’ claim, it was treated as denied, clearing the way for her to file the federal case.
Martens was not the only Minnesotan swept up in the enforcement push that put her in the agents’ path. The operation ran for weeks across the Twin Cities area and drew sustained criticism from local officials over how agents identified themselves and used force against bystanders and protesters, reporting from the period shows. Martens’ attorneys argue the same pattern described in other complaints — unmarked vehicles, no clear announcement of law enforcement authority, weapons drawn on people who were not resisting — is what happened to their client, who they say was simply a bystander observing the operation rather than a participant in it.
Nurses have spent the last several years getting told, correctly, to document everything and trust the process when something happens to them at work. This case is a reminder that the instinct doesn’t stop at the hospital doors. If Martens’ account holds up, a nurse who was doing nothing more than watching from a public place ended up with a re-aggravated joint injury and, by her account, a diagnosis she didn’t have before. Whatever anyone thinks about immigration enforcement itself, the use-of-force standard for someone who isn’t resisting arrest doesn’t change because of who's doing the detaining.
Martens has not been charged with any crime connected to the encounter. Her lawsuit is a civil claim over how she alleges federal agents treated her, and it will now be litigated in federal court.