A Plymouth Superior Court judge on Monday denied Lindsay Clancy’s bid to dismiss the murder case against her, rejecting a double-jeopardy argument that her lawyers had built around September’s mistrial.
Judge William F. Sullivan ruled that the mistrial — declared Sept. 4, 2026, after jurors told the court they were hopelessly deadlocked following roughly 38 hours of deliberation over a week — met the “manifest necessity” standard that lets prosecutors bring the same charges a second time without violating the constitutional ban on double jeopardy, according to CNN and Boston.com. Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse from Duxbury, is charged with murdering her three children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 7 months, in January 2023. She has pleaded not guilty, and her defense has argued that severe postpartum psychosis and the effects of psychiatric medication left her unable to understand what she was doing.
A jury that couldn’t agree, and a judge who found that was enough
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington argued at a Nov. 2 hearing that the deadlock didn’t rise to the level required to let prosecutors retry Clancy, and separately renewed a request for a required finding of not guilty — a request Sullivan had taken under advisement rather than ruling on from the bench that day. Monday’s written order resolved both: Sullivan found the jury’s deadlock itself was manifest necessity for the mistrial, which clears the way for the Plymouth County District Attorney’s office to seek a second trial if it chooses to.
What else the judge decided
Sullivan also denied Reddington’s request to obtain records from, and question, the holdout juror identified in court as Michael Desronvil, ruling that information wasn’t relevant to the dismissal motion. Separately, he turned down prosecutors’ request for a gag order on the attorneys in the case — filed after Reddington gave a round of media interviews — though he said prosecutors could renew that request closer to a second trial if circumstances change, per US News and the Associated Press.
No new trial date has been set. The next hearing, scheduled for Nov. 16, is expected to focus on scheduling rather than substance; multiple outlets reported Sullivan has floated the possibility of a trial as early as March 2027, though prosecutors have not said publicly whether, or when, they intend to retry her.
Why this matters for nurses
I’ve sat with new mothers on a postpartum floor describing racing, violent thoughts they were too frightened to say out loud, and this case is a big part of why more of them are saying it now. Whatever a jury eventually decides about Clancy’s culpability, the record built across her first trial — the medication changes, the missed warning signs, the gap between what she reported feeling and what the people around her understood — keeps forcing a conversation that most postpartum units still treat as a footnote to postpartum depression: psychosis is rarer, it moves faster, and it needs its own screening questions, not a shared checkbox.
Clancy has not been convicted of any charge. Her first trial ended without a verdict, and whether she ever faces a second one is now a decision for prosecutors, not the court.